An investigative committee of Enron's board has released its report on the breakdown of controls and ethics in the company.
Our investigation identified significant problems beyond those Enron
has already disclosed. Enron employees involved in the partnerships
were enriched, in the aggregate, by tens of millions of dollars they
should never have received -- Fastow by at least $30 million, Kopper
by at least $10 million, two others by $1 million each, and still two
more by amounts we believe were at least in the hundreds of thousands
of dollars. We have seen no evidence that any of these employees,
except Fastow, obtained the permission required by Enron's Code of
Conduct of Business Affairs to own interests in the partnerships.
Moreover, the extent of Fastow's ownership and financial windfall was
inconsistent with his representations to Enron's Board of Directors.
This personal enrichment of Enron employees, however, was merely one
aspect of a deeper and more serious problem. These partnerships --
Chewco, LJM1, and LJM2 -- were used by Enron Management to enter into
transactions that it could not, or would not, do with unrelated
commercial entities. Many of the most significant transactions
apparently were designed to accomplish favorable financial statement
results, not to achieve bona fide economic objectives or to
transfer risk. Some transactions were designed so that, had they
followed applicable accounting rules, Enron could have kept assets and
liabilities (especially debt) off of its balance sheet; but the
transactions did not follow those rules.
The report is a 9 meg PDF. Here are some summaries:
- Enron Panel Finds Inflated Profits and Few Controls
- Panel Finds Rush to Hide Losses and Enrich a Few
- Top Executives Blamed in Enron's Fall
- Report Highlights
- How executives made millions in hidden deals