The end of the beginning?: Paul Kingsnorth reviews this year's World Social Forum in Porto Alegre, which shows the anti-globalization movement is turning more and more constructive.
In just a few years, this movement has instituted a real debate about values, economics and power. Through our numbers on the streets, through the work of key dissident thinkers and through the actions of vast grassroots movements in the Global South we have gone from being ignored, or sneered at, to being grudgingly respected.
Already, less than three years after the "Battle of Seattle", we are at the stage where the president of the World Bank can be turned away from our Social Forum (oh, the joy!); at the point where the French government sends twice as many ministers to Porto Alegre (six) as to New York (three).
See also Anti-globalization - a spreading phenomenon, where the Canadian Security Intelligence Service surveys the anti-globalization movement.